Two sections: how Social Security decides whether you qualify, and how injury money actually works once a settlement is on the table.
Many of our clients have the same questions about applying for Social Security benefits and what our office offers. This section is here to help you understand what is required to get approved. Remember — we do the work to prove your case.
Social Security uses a five-step process.
There are two programmes available to most disabled people. SSD means Social Security Disability Insurance. SSI means Supplemental Security Income. They have different rules and different purposes, and people often qualify for one but not the other.
Everybody who earns money by working pays Social Security contributions. The basic rule is that after you stop working you remain eligible for disability benefits based on those earnings for about five years.
Put another way, roughly five of the last ten years before you apply need to show earnings at the level of substantial gainful activity. That figure is currently about $1,040 per month and has risen over time with inflation. Social Security computes this in quarters.
To find out whether you have earned enough, go to ssa.gov/myaccount, where you can also see what your disability benefit would be.
If you do not qualify for SSD, or your SSD will not bring you up to the SSI benefit level (currently around $700 per month), and you are disabled, you may qualify for SSI. This programme is needs-based, so your resources have to be limited.
You may not, for example, have more than $2,000 cash on hand or in the bank — or $3,000 for a couple. You are allowed to have a house, a car, and certain other assets.
Resources that count against eligibility include:
Resources that do not count include:
There are more. If you have a question, give us a call.
These answers are general explanations. Everyone's situation is different, and the whole reason for the law and for lawyers is to find the best legal solution for an individual case.
Most cases are contingency fees. That means we take a percentage of what we recover for you. If we do not recover any money, we do not get a fee.
A contingency fee is a risk-sharing arrangement. We take the risk that we will do far more work than the fee justifies; you take the risk that the case settles easily. Sometimes you do well and sometimes not. Without contingency fees, though, someone who could not afford to pay a lawyer by the hour could not get a lawyer at all.
Our fee is a percentage of the settlement amount, which sounds simpler than it is. Two things matter.
First, how far along the case is. The first phase is gathering information and trying to settle; we charge 33⅓% there. The second phase is filing suit, doing discovery and preparing for arbitration or trial; we charge 36% at that point. If we start trial, we charge 40%. Appeals may be more, and we negotiate that fee when it comes up.
Second, what the settlement is. Typically someone comes to us having had some bills paid by insurance and maybe holding a small settlement offer. We charge our percentage on the gross settlement, which includes amounts that have to be repaid. You may disagree about whether that is fair — but it is what we charge, and it is what you agree to by signing the fee agreement.
Fees are never written in stone. For good reason we may be willing to change the agreement upfront, and if it becomes unreasonable for us to charge a fee — a term defined in law and governed by ethical rules — we may have to reduce it.
We do not give tax advice. What follows is what we have been able to find; if you need a certain answer we can refer you to a tax lawyer.
Generally, personal injury proceeds are treated as compensation for injuries and losses rather than a gain or windfall, so they are not taxable. If the award compensates for physical injury or sickness, it is not taxable. An emotional injury flowing from a physical injury may not be taxable, but an emotional injury from a non-physical injury is. Lost wages resulting from physical injury may not be taxable.
If somebody else pays your medical bills and you later recover money for those same bills from the responsible driver's insurer, you have to pay it back. You do not get to recover twice for the same item of damage. This is called subrogation.
Usually the repayment is reduced by the same percentage of fees and costs you pay on the overall settlement. We can also argue about which bills are related to the accident and which are not, and sometimes we get repayment waived entirely.
As with everything else, the exceptions depend on who paid the bills.
Under federal law we must obtain your Social Security number, notify Social Security when you receive a settlement, and give Medicare the chance to tell us what it claims is due. By law we cannot simply hand that money to you. If we disagree with Medicare, we have to hold the funds in trust while their appeal process runs.
Be aware that Medicare takes the position it can claim reimbursement for bills only vaguely related to an accident — or even unrelated, if incurred around the time of it — and the courts have upheld that. Medicare is not unreasonable about its rights, but it is bureaucratic and slow, and months are not uncommon.
Medicaid and DSHS are easier to work with and are required to limit reimbursement to items actually caused by the accident. We generally negotiate over that, since it is often the central issue in a case anyway.
This can be a minefield. If health insurance is provided as an employee benefit, some insurers use ERISA to assert they are entitled to 100% reimbursement regardless of the effect on the insured person.
Private insurers, on the other hand, have contract provisions requiring reimbursement but are subject to law saying you need not reimburse them unless you are "fully compensated" — a debatable concept. Sometimes private insurers get nothing back. Our policy is to negotiate a reasonable reimbursement whenever possible.
You may have Personal Injury Protection or Med Pay coverage — and you should get it if you do not. The rules differ depending on whose policy it is.
If you have first-party PIP, you will have to repay those benefits, less fees and costs, out of any third-party settlement. PIP is usually more liberal about paying for treatment that a third-party insurer might call unrelated, and we have sometimes succeeded in getting a PIP carrier to waive subrogation on that basis.
Then there is shared fault. In any accident there may be comparative fault — 80/20, 70/30, and so on. If the other side is only 70% at fault, they pay 70% of your damages. PIP, by contrast, is no-fault: you get it even if you were entirely at fault. When it comes to reimbursement we sometimes argue that because the settlement was reached on a shared-fault basis, the PIP carrier is not entitled to be repaid for your share of the fault. If you received $5,000 in PIP and we settle on the basis that you were 40% at fault, we argue that 40% of the PIP payments were never recovered from the third party and you should only repay 60%, less fees and costs.
If the other driver has PIP, they may pay your bills but will take credit for it against your eventual recovery.
One more thing: Washington has a rule known as the Mahler rule, from a significant court case, requiring the insurer to participate in fees and costs — the same percentage reduces their repayment as the client pays on the total recovery. Insurers sometimes resolve subrogation through intercompany arbitration, which can result in a payment going to the client. If this arises we will try to explain it, if we can work it out ourselves.
A lien is an ownership right granted to a third party against money being held by the attorney — much like a mortgage, or a bank's security interest in a car you are buying. Liens are created by statute and create real problems for lawyers, because of our obligations both to our clients and to third parties.
When we recover money and part of it belongs to someone else, we must place it in our trust account first, determine who it belongs to, and then pay it out. The rules say any money belonging to a client must be given to the client on demand — but also that where ownership is disputed, we may not release it to anybody until the dispute is resolved, either by negotiation or, rarely, by paying it into court.
Liens are rarely written in concrete. Their validity, and more importantly their amount, is often in dispute. We will often hold the maximum claimed amount in trust while we resolve it, and pay the difference back to you if it comes out lower.
What kinds of liens are there?
Attorney fees are subject to a lien under RCW 60.40.010, and that lien is superior to all others. That sounds self-serving — and to some extent it is — but without it every lien dispute would create a conflict of interest and we would have to withdraw from the case.
Medical providers may create a lien under RCW 60.44.010 by recording a written document with the County Auditor, and the total of those liens may not exceed 25% of the gross recovery.
Medicare, Medicaid, DSHS, Workers' Compensation, the VA and others may have liens by statute, often federal statute, and those are generally very enforceable.
Doctors, settlement loan companies and others may have clients sign documents creating an assignment of proceeds and call it a loan. Our position is that if we do not agree to be bound by such agreements, they are not effective — and our fee agreement provides for that.
Have a question that is not answered here? Call us at 509-462-0827.
Request an appointmentThat is what the free consultation is for. No charge, no obligation.